We receive advertising fees from the brands we review that affect the ranking and scoring of such brands.
Advertiser Disclosure

Cash Stuffing Trend: Is it Worth Missing Out on 5% Returns?

Elinor Rozenvasser Updated: October 25, 2023 • 3 min read
envelope being used as a savings account

Key Points:

  • A resurgence of an age-old budgeting technique called "cash stuffing" is gaining popularity, especially among young adults.

  • Cash stuffing is referred as dividing spending into envelopes to provide a hands-on approach to budgeting.

  • There are some risks to keeping cash at home, ones that high-yield savings accounts may solve.

In a financial landscape reshaped by a series of interest rate hikes, savers are presented with an unprecedented opportunity. Online savings accounts are now offering returns exceeding 5%, marking a significant upswing in potential gains. Yet, a curious trend has emerged – the resurgence of cash stuffing, a method gaining traction, particularly among young adults. This age-old budgeting approach divides spending into envelopes, allotting a set amount for various expenses. While it provides a real sense of financial control, it comes with trade-offs.

Let’s dissect the pros and cons of cash stuffing, shedding light on why high-yield savings accounts might be the more lucrative path to financial security.

Exploring the option of a high-yield savings account may ultimately lead to more savings.

What is Cash Stuffing?

The envelope method, popularized on TikTok, harks back to a simpler era of budgeting. It divides monthly expenses into tangible envelopes, ensuring that once the cash is spent, the spending limit for that category is reached.

Ted Rossman, senior industry analyst at Bankrate, acknowledges its effectiveness in instilling discipline, offering a reasonable method to stay on budget. However, he also cautions that it might not be the most optimal financial strategy.

The Downsides of Cash Stuffing

While cash stuffing provides a tactile approach to budgeting, it lacks the protection offered in traditional banking. Theft poses a significant risk, and coverage may depend on your home insurance policy. In stark contrast, banks are insured by the FDIC, guaranteeing up to $250,000 per depositor, per account ownership category. Greg McBride, chief financial analyst at Bankrate, highlights another downside - the missed opportunity to earn potentially up to 5% on your savings.

Quontic Online Bank Logo
Quontic Banking
  • No monthly/overdraft fees
  • Low minimum deposits
Visit Site
Patriot Bank Logo
Patriot Bank
  • Enjoy a 0.70% APY high-yield
  • Personalized products for your goals
Visit Site
Axos Bank
  • Earn up to 0.61% APY
  • Up to $200 Bonus for High-Yield Savings
Visit Site

Optimizing Savings: High-Yield Accounts

Financial experts advise against cash stuffing over high-yield savings accounts. Matt Schulz, Chief Credit Analyst at LendingTree, emphasizes the significance of even small gains in a paycheck-to-paycheck situation.

For example, a $5,000 deposit at 5% yields $250 in interest annually, showcasing a substantial potential gain. Moreover, alternative options like Treasury bills, certificates of deposit, and money market accounts offer competitiveness, although they may require locking in savings for a set period.

Savings Option Potential Gains Lock-in Period
High-yield savings account Up to 5% on deposits Flexible
Treasury builds Competitive rates Fixed term
Certificates of deposit Competitive rates Fixed term
Money market accounts Competitive rates Flexible

Navigating Financial Advice on Social Media

Getting advice about money on social media can be really helpful, but not all advice is the same. Howard Dvorkin, who knows a lot about money, says it's smart to also get advice from trusted places like the National Foundation for Credit Counseling or the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. He warns that only using places like TikTok or Instagram for money advice can be tricky because it's hard to know if the people giving advice are really experts or have your best interests in mind.

The Bottom Line

In today's financial landscape, you have a unique opportunity to make your savings work harder for you. When choosing between cash stuffing and high-yield savings accounts, it's essential to consider the advantages and drawbacks of each option. While cash stuffing provides tangible control over your budget, it may not offer the same level of protection and potential earnings as high-yield accounts.

Exploring the option of a high-yield savings account may ultimately lead to more savings. It's all about making an informed choice that suits your specific circumstances and goals.


Elinor Rozenvasser is a content writer and editor with a knack for finance. She holds a Bachelor's in Communications and Business from Reichman University, and has been swimming alongside finance specialists for over a decade. She's not your typical financial writer, though. She's more likely to use witty puns and sarcasm than jargon and technical terms. But don't let that fool you. She's still a whiz when it comes to explaining complex financial concepts in a way that anyone can understand. If there's any writer who can make finance fun and engaging, Elinor is your girl. She's sure to leave you laughing (and learning) long after you've finished reading her work.