We receive advertising fees from the brands we review that affect the ranking and scoring of such brands.
Advertiser Disclosure

Select Home Warranty vs. American Home Shield Comparison

Compare providers side-by-side, allowing for easy comparison of features, rates, and terms. The comparison tool encourages individuals to thoroughly review all aspects of each service before making a smart financial decision.

+

Add a brand

Overview drop-down-btn

Home Warranty

Visit site >

Home Warranty

Visit Site >
Home Warranty drop-down-btn
Good For
$150 Off + Free Roof Coverage
Good For
Plans & pricing to fit every budget
Payout Caps

$2,000 limit per system or $500 for appliances

Payout Caps

$0 – $6,000

Service Fees
Service Fees
Pros
  • Signup perks available, including $100 off per year or two months free
  • Free roof coverage available
  • Unlimited number of customer repairs available
Pros
  • No home inspection required
  • Members can choose their own contractor in special cases
  • Large network of 17,000 contractors
Cons
  • cons Requires annual maintenance reports
  • cons Does not cover service from contractors outside their network
Cons
  • cons Not available in Alaska
  • cons Plan prices vary depending on size of home and location
+